McCoy Jeweler

Roger Peterson

5 months ago

Such a friendly atmosphere! The staff were absolutely amazing - so welcoming and willing to help in any way they could. I brought in a sentimental piece of jewelry for repair, and they did a fantastic job! I couldn’t be happier with the results. Highly recommend this place for any jewelry repair needs.

Jaderial Staebler

3 weeks ago

McCoy's has been incredibly patient, kind, and helpful as my fiancé and I designed our wedding bands. We could not be happier with the rings and the personalized customer service! Thanks so much, McCoy's!

Carey Howard

month ago

I had an incredibly meaningful experience with McCoy Jewelers. They took my wedding ring and my late husband’s ring and transformed them into one beautiful, timeless heirloom piece. The gold from both rings was carefully melted together, and the diamonds were thoughtfully and strategically set to create something truly unique. What could have been a simple redesign became something so much more — a piece filled with memory, craftsmanship, and intention. They handled the entire process with such care, respect, and attention to detail, which meant everything to me. I now have a ring that not only honors our story, but that I can cherish for the rest of my life and pass down for generations. I’m so grateful for their artistry and compassion — I couldn’t recommend McCoy Jewelers more.

Elise Henry

3 weeks ago

We always have the best experience at Mccoy! My fiancé and I came in for my engagement band and we loved the team and experience so much we just recently went back to purchase wedding bands! 1000% would recommend to anyone!

Leah Cafarelli

4 weeks ago

Had fantastic experiences at McCoy for both my engagement ring & wedding band! It feels really special to have unique, custom rings (and surprisingly affordable)! And their customer service is top notch. Definitely recommend!

Ben Klein

3 weeks ago

McCoy went above and beyond for our Wedding. Even with a bit of a time constraint, they were still able to deliver great customer service and build the ring(s) we envisioned. All the staff are knowledgeable and take pride in what they do. Highly recommend!

Jack Jaros

4 weeks ago

McCoy’s has been such a joy to work with. Everyone there is so friendly and they make your moment feel so special from the start. It was a special treat to watch my fiancée pick out her ring. They are so helpful and our time there resulted in rings that we absolutely love. I’m so glad we chose McCoy’s!

Allison & Jake Rheingans

2 weeks ago

We had an incredible experience working with Samantha at McCoy! She was very patient and walked us through so many options for both my engagement ring and our wedding bands. She is incredibly knowledgeable and we got to learn so much from her. 10/10 recommend anyone to go to McCoy!

Allison Krapfl

2 weeks ago

McCoy is amazing! Working with them throughout this entire process has been seamless. They have a wide variety and if they don’t have it, they’re willing to customize anything. Savannah was so helpful throughout the process. We love our rings!

Callie Wiegel

2 weeks ago

Truly had such an amazing experience at McCoy! My fiancé and I went here to get our wedding bands after he said he had such a smooth experience getting my engagement ring! I never felt pressured to purchase anything and never felt judged for my personal style. Everyone was so welcoming and friendly! Also, there was a dog there when we went and he was the cutest boy! Would definitely recommend coming to McCoy for that special moment and every moment in between!